Comments (0) 12:00 AM posted by admin |
More often than not, local Ypsilanti news is overlooked by the Ann Arbor News.
When they do report it, like the failed ordinance designed as a pro-land use device to preserve the downtown, they get it wrong by calling it a measure to bar churches. Other times, the News blows it by not even writing an article at all, like they did by ignoring the impressive throng of people who turned out in support of saving the bus subsidy.
That’s not to say that alternative media outlets like this are not at fault. Admittedly I’ve probably been sitting on the best feel-good news story of the year. For that, I apologize.
And without further delay…
HUD has cancelled the proposed sale of the Parkview Apartments to notorious New York City slumlord Emmanuel Ku after the Parkview Tenants Association successfully sued HUD in Federal court. Score one for the good guys.
Someone else’s words are usually more eloquent than mine, so I’ll just reprint them for your enjoyment.
Weâ€™re sending this report to update you on the current status of the efforts of the Parkview Tenants Association (PTA) to maintain Parkview Apartments as their housing and to require the ownersâ€”HUD and the Parkview Apartments Non-Profit Corporation (PVANPC)â€”to resolve the title issues in a way that protects the tenantsâ€™ interests and begins to bring the property into compliance with city and state housing laws.
As background, Parkview is a 144-unit, HUD-subsidized apartment complex on the south side of Ypsilanti. There have been serious repair issues documented at the premises for many years. A 2004 inspection by the City of Ypsilanti documented 953 building code violations at Parkview; that inspection found only 7 of the 144 units in compliance with the code. In 2003, HUD became very directly involved in the projectâ€”in order to protect its asset, to protect the tenants, and to protect the community.
In 2004, HUD decided to foreclose on the property and to re-sell it to a local governmental unit. The property was initially scheduled for sale in November, 2004. At that time, HUD had selected the Ypsilanti Housing Commission as the local governmental entity to assume title to the project. However, the PVANPC sued to enjoin the sale. That suit was dismissed, but the sale was delayed.
On May 27, 2005, HUD auctioned Parkview Apartments at a public foreclosure sale.
The tenants were disappointed in how HUD handled that sale. Shortly before the sale and after a drawn out negotiation, the City of Ypsilanti (City) and the Ypsilanti Housing Commission (YHC) executed a Memorandum of Understanding approving the sale of Parkview to the YHC; the tenants understood that, under the City-YHC agreement, HUD would acquire the property and sell it to the YHC. Under the YHC proposal, the property would be managed by Chesapeake Properties (a well respected low income project manager). The YHC proposal provided for at least $3.5 million dollars in renovations and repairs to the property. But HUD said the City-YHC agreement was made too late and refused to postpone the sale. The property was then sold to the highest bidderâ€”Emmanuel Ku a/k/a/ Dakko Properties (Mr. Ku).
Since the sale, the current Parkview ownership, PVANPC, has continued to fight HUD and to try to avoid losing control over the propertyâ€”while continuing to neglect the property. On June 1, 2005, PVANPC filed a Chapter 11 petition in the U.S. Bankruptcy Court. The bankruptcy placed a stay on HUDâ€™s sale to Mr. Ku.
After learning of HUDâ€™s decision to sell to Mr. Ku, the tenants did some research on his record as a property manager. The tenants learned that Mr. Ku has a history of maintenance and code compliance problems with apartments that he owns or manages in New York City. These concerns were substantiated by an affidavit from a high ranking official in the NYC code enforcement department. From the tenantsâ€™ perspective, there was another problem with Mr. Kuâ€™s bidâ€” it provided for only $1 million for repairs and renovation of the propertyâ€”about $2.5 million less than the YHC proposal. The tenants believe that this amount is wholly inadequate to address the hundreds of documented housing code violations at the property.
In June 2005, the PTA sent a letter to HUD requesting that HUD perform its due diligence as required by Section 219 of the Consolidated Appropriations Act 2004 by reviewing the bidderâ€™s record for compliance with state and local housing laws before certifying the bidder as a qualified purchaser. The PTA urged HUD to cancel the sale to Mr. Ku. HUD refused to cancel the sale.
In October 2005, the PTA filed a Proof of Claim in Parkviewâ€™s bankruptcy case to protect the tenantsâ€™ security deposits and raising a claim for a retroactive rent abatement, as supported by the hundreds of code violations that have existed at Parkview for years.
In November, HUD got permission from the bankruptcy court (relief from the bankruptcy stay) to close the sale of Parkview to Mr. Ku.
HUDâ€™s continuing refusal to cancel the sale to Mr. Ku forced the PTA to sue HUD in the Federal District Court. This suit was filed in December, 2005 and asked the Court to enjoin HUD from selling Parkview to Mr. Ku.
On February 14, 2006, HUD decided to cancel the sale of property to Mr. Ku. The decision by HUD grants the PTA the relief sought in their suitâ€”so this pending case will be resolved.
A HUD official has told us that HUD intends to ask the bankruptcy court to allow it to become the Mortgagee in Possession (MIP) of the property. As MIP, HUD intends to begin making repairs and security improvements to the property.
Regrettably, the situation at Parkview is worse now than it was it was in the fall of 2004 when HUD first scheduled the property for saleâ€”hundreds of code violations, virtually no security, no progress on repairs. And, since PVANPC has refused to pay its water bills, the tenants were all served with utility shut off notices just before Christmas. (YUCA subsequently agreed to hold off on these shut offs.)
We see the current time as an opportunity for the community. This is our collective chance to take joint action to improve Parkview. The PTA has asked for a meeting with HUD to discuss HUDâ€™s future plans for the property. However, this is not a problem that HUD can solve on its own. The support and participation of state and local government is critical in planning and implementing a solution that addresses everyoneâ€™s goals.
At this time, the PTA needs your support and advocacy. Please contact HUD and urge it to engage in discussions with PTA and other community stakeholders. Urge HUD to immediately ask the bankruptcy court to give it MIP status. Assuming HUD becomes MIP, urge it to quickly begin the long neglected repairs to the property; to immediately improve the security situation there; and then to make a commitment to selling Parkview to the YHC or another qualified non-profit entity committed to preserving the property as decent and affordable housing for Ypsilantiâ€™s very low income residents.
On behalf of the PTA, we appreciate your past concerns for the property and the tenants. We urge you to become involved again at this critical moment. The PTA hopes it can count on your continued support of its efforts to bring safe and decent affordable housing to the residents of Parkview. If you have any questions or concerns, please contact Jim Schaafsma [734-998-6100, ext. 21]; or Bob Gillett [734-665-6181]; or Min Kim [734-665-6181].
Note: The PTA continues to be represented by Legal Services of South Central Michiganâ€”in addition, Gary Boren of Boren & Carey PC, and the University of Michigan Clinical Law Program (Paul Reingold), are assisting LSSCM on a pro bono basis.
Legal Services of South Central Michigan
This isn’t to say the current Ypsilanti City Council won’t up and give the project to Wesley Finch for a hundred bucks, but for the time being, Ypsilanti has been spared at least one more slumlord.
No Comments »
No comments yet.